Introduction
The present edition of the Academy of Armory


1. Editing the text
2. The index
3. Editing the drawings

1. Editing the text
Appreciating the fascination and importance of Randle Holme's text is made very difficult by its extensive overlay of heraldic material.To make its social historical content more accessible we have aimed to clarify the text while retaining as much as possible of Holme's original wording. The Academy is an important source for the construction of the Dictionary of traded goods and commodities 1550-1800 being undertaken by the ongoing Dictionary Project at the University of Wolverhampton, and the initial digitization of most of the text was undertaken for the Dictionary. A decision was made to excise the heraldic material and, for readibility, not to mark these omissions in the text, a policy that has been retained in this edition. The following example compares the original and edited texts.
Original text [Book III, Ch. 6 no. 6] Edited text
VI. He beareth Argent, a Flax Brake, Gules. This is an Instrument of Housewifery, by which both Flax and Hemp are first broken from the strong Stalks into large Shoves or Shivers. This is a Coat Armor belonging to the name of Hambrake.
V.3 such O [Vert three flax brakes Or] is born by Nabler.
VI. He beareth a Flax Brake. This is an Instrument of Housewifery, by which both Flax and Hemp are first broken from the strong Stalks into large Shoves or Shivers.

Within the Academy, we decided to exclude those chapters which cover only heraldic descriptions, mythology and general natural history, but retaining discussion of domestic plants and animals. The whole of Book III and part of Book II have been included but Books I and IV are omitted, together with the rest of Book II (chapters I, VI, VIII, X-XVI); the Table of Contents lists this material. In the selected chapters of Book II, all the images are included, but only relevant sections of the text have been transcribed. Similarly, Book III retains all the images but omits a small number of lengthy historical, legal, religious and similar commentaries; complete omitted sections are listed as 'untranscribed' and within sections of the text, excisions are identified by a series of dots.
Two principles governed the initial digitization:
(1) The retention of the framework and order of the original work;
(2) The introduction of flexibility in organizing the material so that a more rational order could be created when desired in the original fairly chaotic text.
To achieve these conflicting objectives, the edited text was typed into a database (FoxPro). Each record included a full text transcription of a discrete portion of text, with the addition of a descriptive title, references to locate the original text and picture pages, and a compact unique identifier consisting of the original chapter, section, image number and a code (t or p for text or picture). The text was selected almost entirely from the two published volumes although, at a late stage we added a few sections only in manuscript, scored through by Randle Holme. For the second (1905) volume we followed the printed text in retaining the distinctive spelling conventions, especially the interchangeable use of 'v' and 'u'; the spelling in the 1688 volume is much more standardised and probably in a form more nearly as Randle Holme intended. We have retained his capitalisation throughout. As the preparation of the edition proceeded, it became clear that the printed text contains many typographical errors, as well as idiosyncratic spellings; the latter have been left unaltered, but obvious misprints producing nonsense words have been corrected.
The confusion over Randle Holme's intentions in the final chapters of Book III had to be addressed. It was decided to ignore the arrangement adopted by J.H. Jeayes in 1905 and to adopt what seemed the most logical arrangement (as discussed in the first part of the Introduction (The Academy of Armory: The text). The chapters he labelled 21 and 22 have been restored to their original numbering as chapters 20 and 21. The two final chapters in the manuscript (chapter 20, parts 1 and 2 in the 1905 edition) are relabelled as chapter 18b and 19b respectively.
For the edition, an initial decision was taken that the use of HTML gave ideal flexibility and the ability to cross-link the varied text and images; in effect we created a large stand-alone web site, which was then published as a CD-ROM. The text database was transferred to PARADOX-4, chosen because of Nat Alcock's familiarity with its script language (PAL). The compact FOXPRO identifier was expanded into separate control fields so that each record contains all the information needed to generate the final HTML files automatically. The fields in the database are as follows:
Field Comments
Book Either 2 or 3 for Book II or III. This field is redundant because of the encoding of the chapter field, but is useful for sorting and referencing
Chapter Book IIIc Chapters 1-21 are numbered directly, but for Book II 30 is added to the chapter number (e.g. 32 for chapter 2, 48 for chapter 18), to give unique references.
Chaplett When a chapter refers to more than one plate, this identifies the plate as a, b or c.
Section When Randle Holme gave section numbers, these are used. In the absence of original section numbers, convenient numbering has been inserted.
Sub-section If Randle Holme's original sections were inconveniently long, they have been subdivided for convenience. Each section/subsection corresponds to a directory in the final file structure, containing no more than about 20 images and their associated texts.
Number The number is that of the corresponding picture or, when there is no picture directly associated with the text, that picture immediately preceding the text section. Each section/subsection starts with a record numbered 0. This includes any text Randle Holme gave as a preface to the section.
Lettera Either p for a picture record or x for a non-picture record
Letterb A running letter a, b, .. identifies the images in one picture square or the distinct text sections.
Picno This indicates how many picture files are associated with each picture record, (normally 1, but occasionally up to 3). Additionally,
0 is used when no drawing survives and the proof plate image has to be used
-1 identifies an image absent from the proof plate and taken from the published plate
-2 identifies an image absent from the proof plate when no published version exists
-3 identifies series of picture records without images
Content A memo field giving the item text
Desc A description of the item, usually the original title, with the spelling modernised


In all the database contains 5501 records, 4120 with pictures, 1072 with text only and 409 section or chapter headings. The text includes about 350,000 words.
Before the HTML files were created, each text record was pre-processed to insert cross-references and links to bibliographic citations. Paragraph identifiers, that would be converted to HTML targets, were also added. The scripts to generate the HTML files operate on each section as a unit, transferring the title and descriptive text for each picture record to one file and generating the links to the picture images. Similarly, the unillustrated text records in the section make up a text file. Separate scripts are used to generate the small files that display the high resolution versions of each image and the manuscript pages.

2. The Index
Compiling the index to Randle Holme's text, even in its edited form, proved to be one of the most onerous and technically difficult aspects of the project. As a first stage, the complete contents and description records were processed to produce a database of keywords, each accompanied by a context phrase and link. After correcting misprints, this table contained 354,000 records, referring to 24,000 keywords (of two letters or more) (Footnote 1). Because of Holme's arbitrary use of capitalisation, all the keywords were converted to lower case (including proper nouns). This lengthy list was reduced to 14,000 standardised keywords in which varieties of word form as well as spelling are combined. In general, verbs are given as infinitives (except where used adjectivally) and nouns are singular unless the plural form has a distinct meaning.
Finally, a selected keyword list was made, principally of those nouns and adjectives that seem most useful as index terms. Although the list was reduced only to 11,000 words, the total number of references dropped to 104,000; the number of keywords is expanded by the long lists of terms given by Holme, notably as beggar's cant and mariner's words; his Latin names of medicines have been eliminated from the selected word index to reduce its length.
The choice, both of standard spellings and of selected keywords, proved very difficult and we are not certain whether either process greatly enhances the usefulness of the index for readers. We therefore decided to create indexes from all three lists. Thus, additional usages of words exactly as cited by Randle Holme can be located in the 'original spelling' index, while even the commonest words can be found in the 'standard' index. This may be particularly useful for searching homonyms; for example, the noun can is buried among the verb forms. It was decided that individual words should either be completely included or excluded from the selected word index, so that only one index needs to be searched.
Using the Index
One technical aspect of the index should be noted. Because some of the link files are very large, they take a significant time to load. Clicking on a word opens the main text in a new window, so that the index files do not have to be reloaded before looking at another reference. Thus, to switch between index and text, either view both windows together, each reduced to about half the height of the full screen, or click alternately on the two Netscape windows on the taskbar. To find a particular word, click in the keyword frame and then type CNTL-F to search for the word.

3. Editing the drawings

The 247 pages of Holme's manuscripts that include drawings were scanned with the British Library's digital camera, to give a series of very high resolution TIFF files, each more than 20 MB in size. Generating the illustrations from these was lengthy but straightforward, using Adobe Photoshop. Each individual drawing was clipped and edited, if necessary, to remove confusing lines belonging to adjacent images; for a few very faint images, the contrast had to be increased. Two copies were then saved; the first was at full resolution, to display the maximum information about the image (footnote 2); the second, image was reduced in size to minimize its loading time. This version was resampled at 2/3rds resolution and down-sized to a standard height of 120 or 180 pixels, depending on the height of the original image; if the original after resampling was less than 120 pixels high, it was not further reduced.
For the illustrations of whole pages and the full page versions of the engraved plates, the originals were simply reduced to about 2/3rds resolution and saved as .jpg files; they can be clicked to view them at large scale. Smaller versions, scaled to a height of 600 pixels, were prepared for the manuscript page displays. Similarly, for the thumbnails used in the picture index, the plates were reduced to about one third resolution before clipping.
[Note: These reduced-size images are retained on the TATHS website, since it is not practicable to re-edit each drawing and replace them in the image folders.]
As the drawings were prepared, information about each was recorded in a database, particularly to identify its page source and location on the page; the locations are in a letter sequence, normally in columns unless RH clearly aligned the images in rows. Handling the pages of jottings proved difficult, as their subjects tend to be very heterogeneous and the images on these pages have been less fully indexed.

Identifying the images
The initial impression on glancing at the manuscript, of innumerable fascinating but confusing images, was totally confirmed as they were studied in detail. Only on a very few pages do the pictures follow the order on the final plates, while rather more pages have the images grouped by subject, though sometimes they relate to more than one plate. Within the Harleian volumes, linked topics are scattered, even to the extent of two halves of one original sheet being bound up in different volumes.
Despite this confusion, identifying the images was generally relatively easy, usually by matching them with the corresponding printed plate. For the sections whose plates have not survived (chapters 18b and 19b-21), groups of draft drawings could mostly be identified from the labels on the drawings. Only where these labels were absent did each drawing need to be compared very closely with the written texts. It was particularly gratifying towards the end of this phase of the project, when the number of sections lacking drawings became relatively small, to recognise on H.2034, f.210 the unlabelled drawings for the gardener's and the wax-chandler's tools, and to realise that the latter continued on H.2027, f.408v with the remarkable small group of torch-maker's tools, though we are defeated by the identity of the spiky tongs in the centre of this page, as perhaps was Randle Holme himself (if this is indeed his un-named tool number 77).
Several pages contain additional drawings clearly relating to their main theme, but not included on the engraved plates. These have been appended at appropriate places in the corresponding chapter. Ultimately, only Jeweller's and Brazier's tools and Masonry in chapter 20, and the Cook and Fisherman in chapter 21 remain without surviving illustrations.
In all, slightly more than 2,500 unique drawings have been identified, with 200 duplicates which provide additional information; another 800 duplicates are listed with the corresponding large-scale drawing, with links to their manuscript page; other duplicates exist, particularly on the jottings pages and on the plate-layout drawings which are not fully indexed. When alternative images exist, the final drawing has generally been chosen, sometimes supplemented by a draft version; images from the plate layout drawings have only been used if no others exist. In Book III, 690 drawings could not be located and the corresponding images from the engraved plates have been used. Some of the proof plates were re-worked before publication, with extra images inserted into blank spaces, so 100 illustrations have had to be taken from the published rather than the proof plates. For Book II, the original drawings of plants and animals have not been sought out; we felt that RH's re-drawing of a leopard or a cypress, certainly from a previous publication, was of less significance than his drawing of (say) a hat. Thus, in Book II, 980 illustrations are taken from the plates and only 12 from drawings.

Footnotes


1. At each stage of index preparation, misprints were found; although all those recognised have been corrected in the main text and in the keywords, a few remain in the context phrases. For the same reason, a very few of the links point to the text file rather than the picture file (or vice versa), because of last-minute corrections to the data, for which it was not possible to amend the index files.

2. A few very wide images had to be reduced slightly in size so that they can be viewed satisfactorily.